The great revenge novel, serialized from 1844 and never out of print since. Dumas took a real police-archive case and built from it a machine of patience, fortune, and retribution that runs for over a thousand pages without slackening. It is pulp in the best sense, gloriously plotted, but it also asks a harder question than its imitators: whether a man who appoints himself the agent of Providence can stop in time to remain human. Generations of adventure writers, from Stevenson to Dumas's countless screen adaptors, have lived off this template, and few have matched it.

The case for it, the case against, and the rest of the canon open with Pro.